Open Problem 08

The Optimal Restriction

When does restricting a gift help, and when does it harm?

Status: open
What would count as progress

Evidence from natural experiments or trials on how restriction affects outcomes, including the conditions under which each kind of funding works better.

Why it matters

The case for unrestricted funding is strong but mostly built on surveys of what charities prefer. A science of giving needs outcome evidence, including any cases where restriction does better.

Where to start

Large shifts toward unrestricted giving, such as funders that relaxed restrictions in 2020, are natural experiments. Comparing grantee outcomes before and after is a feasible first study.