Charitology

Research history

Current published edition

PR #3: bounded knowledge claim and founding-poem context

As recorded by . This is a dated public record of drafts, changes, sources and review declarations. A page, checksum or merged pull request does not establish a scientific result or independent review.

Edition
edition:2026-10-27-initial
Edition checksum
63af9ab52aa86652f81ea1fac0b7c40aaad46cd8623865918d41ec347f9b2cd3
Projection checksum
08a373e3b85d7ed44d36bc472444b5773f7cbd1dde11f60e0053b3ba4884b65c
Period
inclusive to exclusive.
Starting baseline
Unknown before the recorded capture. Present states are not backdated to January.

JSON retains the complete pinned edition. CSV covers every recorded event in this edition; view filters do not change either download.

Recorded activity and qualification

  • 43Stable records
  • 45Subject versions
  • 43Recorded events
  • 0Review declarations
  • 0Subjects with qualifying source review
  • 0Peer-reviewed manuscripts
  • 0Qualifying research results
  • 1Editorial correction artifacts
  • 2Changed claim subjects
  • 23Open problems
  • 0Partially resolved problems
  • 0Solved problems
  • 0Problems under review
  • 0Unresolved challenges

Qualification follows the exact recorded public declarations. The ledger cannot establish identity, independence, source reading or truth by itself. Editorial corrections, proposed methods and software checks are separate from qualifying research results.

Coverage and limits

40 source entries are covered by this edition. Claim-level records cover only their selected wording and context; they do not qualify a whole manuscript. Source-derived case labels describe the published summaries, not Charitology fieldwork or charity ratings.

  • This initial capture establishes current draft coverage, not a known January baseline or an earlier status history.
  • The one PR-backed artifact is an editorial correction to two claim subjects; it is not a scientific result, independent review or problem resolution.
  • Source-derived case descriptions and manuscript bylines do not establish performed Charitology fieldwork or documented complete human authorship.
  • Public GitHub observations describe only the named objects at their recorded inspection time. An empty returned review list is not proof about reviews elsewhere.

Entry links open the present site. The separate pinned source text retains this edition’s exact archived bytes.

PR #3: bounded knowledge claim and founding-poem context · Artifact · version 1
Source review: draft

artifact:pr-3-editorial-framing

  • No current qualifying whole-entry source/framing review is recorded.

Qualification follows the exact recorded public declarations. The ledger cannot establish identity, independence, source reading or truth by itself.

Versions and exact subjects

Version entries 1–1

Version 1: PR #3: bounded knowledge claim and founding-poem context

Current subject in this edition

Subject checksum
7936f7c866ab53a3fe65764cd65fff2857bbfd985ba8ffc1354a58da9267c1fe
Version checksum
cf913db297db6537ca2e2a4af8bd181ad9fda852eef04c275665f310b8ad10ad
Authorship declaration
unknown; completeness unknown.

Editorial correction · finding: not-applicable

The Depth Census paragraph replaced a claim that nobody had checked with a statement about what Charitology has established. The founding poem received a narrower summary and an editorial note distinguishing literary framing from a history of philanthropy.

Limitations

This source-backed editorial change does not verify the underlying research claims, establish independent human review or solve an open problem. No challenge submission is asserted. Historical poem source files declare October 26; the separately captured current manuscript declares October 25, so the whole manuscripts are not byte-identical.

Funding disclosure
unknown
Conflict disclosure
unknown
Cited evidence
Pinned source capture

No repository source capture is attached to this version. Its public evidence references remain separate.

Exact version fields and declaration references
{
  "adapterVersion": "research-content-v1",
  "authorship": {
    "actorIds": [],
    "complete": false,
    "refs": [],
    "state": "unknown"
  },
  "hash": "cf913db297db6537ca2e2a4af8bd181ad9fda852eef04c275665f310b8ad10ad",
  "id": "version:artifact-pr-3-editorial-framing-v1",
  "previousId": null,
  "recordId": "artifact:pr-3-editorial-framing",
  "sources": [],
  "subject": {
    "conflicts": {
      "note": null,
      "refs": [],
      "state": "unknown"
    },
    "finding": "not-applicable",
    "funding": {
      "note": null,
      "refs": [],
      "state": "unknown"
    },
    "kind": "editorial-correction",
    "limitations": "This source-backed editorial change does not verify the underlying research claims, establish independent human review or solve an open problem. No challenge submission is asserted. Historical poem source files declare October 26; the separately captured current manuscript declares October 25, so the whole manuscripts are not byte-identical.",
    "sources": [
      {
        "locator": null,
        "title": "PR #3: editorial scope and founding-poem framing correction",
        "url": "https://github.com/theguysaccount/charitology/pull/3"
      },
      {
        "locator": null,
        "title": "PR #3 before: problems/the-depth-census",
        "url": "https://github.com/theguysaccount/charitology/blob/905bdd27bb5f16027c3b3ad3c0f5ee3fc18e3e45/src/content/problems/the-depth-census.md"
      },
      {
        "locator": null,
        "title": "PR #3 after: problems/the-depth-census",
        "url": "https://github.com/theguysaccount/charitology/blob/510320528e89f45caa9c42eb5a6eda3d6ad1bede/src/content/problems/the-depth-census.md"
      },
      {
        "locator": null,
        "title": "PR #3 before: journal/ten-dollars",
        "url": "https://github.com/theguysaccount/charitology/blob/905bdd27bb5f16027c3b3ad3c0f5ee3fc18e3e45/src/content/journal/ten-dollars.md"
      },
      {
        "locator": null,
        "title": "PR #3 after: journal/ten-dollars",
        "url": "https://github.com/theguysaccount/charitology/blob/510320528e89f45caa9c42eb5a6eda3d6ad1bede/src/content/journal/ten-dollars.md"
      }
    ],
    "summary": "The Depth Census paragraph replaced a claim that nobody had checked with a statement about what Charitology has established. The founding poem received a narrower summary and an editorial note distinguishing literary framing from a history of philanthropy.",
    "targets": [
      {
        "recordId": "claim:depth-census-knowledge",
        "subjectHash": "6f3b6d06a2d61893e35d33ae513a3959f44f1321c2bd43d30ff95c54b25fe9a3",
        "version": 2
      },
      {
        "recordId": "claim:ten-dollars-framing",
        "subjectHash": "d32dca610a5ca31c8a179497ebcc580f5d4ce05b80b88bfef2c8409ada1f7f59",
        "version": 2
      }
    ],
    "title": "PR #3: bounded knowledge claim and founding-poem context",
    "type": "artifact"
  },
  "subjectHash": "7936f7c866ab53a3fe65764cd65fff2857bbfd985ba8ffc1354a58da9267c1fe",
  "version": 1
}

Timeline in recorded order

Public occurrence time and ledger recording time are different. A coverage baseline records what was present at capture; it does not invent an earlier history.

Events 1–1

Artifact recorded

Recorded order
43; sequence 1 for this record.
Public occurrence
· pr-merge
Recorded in ledger

Record the genuine merged editorial correction and its two exact before/after claim subjects. No reviewer, challenge, research finding or scientific disposition is inferred from the merge or the observed empty review-submission list.

PR #3: bounded knowledge claim and founding-poem context. No challenge is recorded for this artifact.

Changed subject: Scope of the Depth Census knowledge claim

Before · version 1

Charitology’s founding hypothesis, [the Symptom Trap](/diagnosis/symptom-trap/), says the charity system is weighted toward symptoms. Nobody has checked. If the hypothesis is wrong, the field should be the first to say so. If it’s right, the census gives every later effort a baseline to move.

Selected context

Why it matters

9792de6050cabd1ef2715b6145183702a6a1e5f448563b7474d82c066fd64b4e

After · version 2

Charitology’s founding hypothesis, [the Symptom Trap](/diagnosis/symptom-trap/), says the charity system is weighted toward symptoms. Charitology has not established the current mix. If the hypothesis is wrong, the field should be the first to say so. The census would supply a descriptive baseline. Deciding whether a mix is appropriate also requires an explicit standard tied to the goals being considered.

Selected context

Why it matters

6f3b6d06a2d61893e35d33ae513a3959f44f1321c2bd43d30ff95c54b25fe9a3

Changed subject: Framing of the founding poem

Before · version 1

The founding manifesto. In 2026 the name for the science of doing the most good was available for about ten dollars. That says something about the field.

Selected context

No editorial context is recorded for this version.

38c02e1fa76b1065d922ad738ba9b5e71afb266b0b8b5296a2b17d251d3ecfa8

After · version 2

The founding poem uses a ten-dollar domain registration as an image for Charitology’s invitation to study how generosity is aimed.

Selected context

*Editorial note: This manifesto is a poem, not a history of philanthropy. The ten-dollar image is the author’s account of a domain registration. Existing philanthropy, ethics and evaluation fields have long studied giving; the poem’s invitation is to develop and test Charitology’s proposed shared craft.*

d32dca610a5ca31c8a179497ebcc580f5d4ce05b80b88bfef2c8409ada1f7f59

Exact event fields
{
  "actorIds": [],
  "artifact": {
    "recordId": "artifact:pr-3-editorial-framing",
    "subjectHash": "7936f7c866ab53a3fe65764cd65fff2857bbfd985ba8ffc1354a58da9267c1fe",
    "version": 1
  },
  "challengeIds": [],
  "changes": [
    {
      "after": {
        "recordId": "claim:depth-census-knowledge",
        "subjectHash": "6f3b6d06a2d61893e35d33ae513a3959f44f1321c2bd43d30ff95c54b25fe9a3",
        "version": 2
      },
      "before": {
        "recordId": "claim:depth-census-knowledge",
        "subjectHash": "9792de6050cabd1ef2715b6145183702a6a1e5f448563b7474d82c066fd64b4e",
        "version": 1
      }
    },
    {
      "after": {
        "recordId": "claim:ten-dollars-framing",
        "subjectHash": "d32dca610a5ca31c8a179497ebcc580f5d4ce05b80b88bfef2c8409ada1f7f59",
        "version": 2
      },
      "before": {
        "recordId": "claim:ten-dollars-framing",
        "subjectHash": "38c02e1fa76b1065d922ad738ba9b5e71afb266b0b8b5296a2b17d251d3ecfa8",
        "version": 1
      }
    }
  ],
  "hash": "a4e4bd529e5f3d70b1fa636a77a03a42568cb7804b02d337549aa5d2c177a92c",
  "id": "event:artifact-pr-3-editorial-framing-1",
  "observationIds": [
    "observation:pr-3",
    "observation:pr-3-reviews"
  ],
  "occurredAt": "2026-10-26T05:24:43.000Z",
  "ordinal": 43,
  "previousHash": null,
  "previousId": null,
  "reason": "Record the genuine merged editorial correction and its two exact before/after claim subjects. No reviewer, challenge, research finding or scientific disposition is inferred from the merge or the observed empty review-submission list.",
  "recordId": "artifact:pr-3-editorial-framing",
  "recordedAt": "2026-10-27T08:31:31.000Z",
  "refs": [
    {
      "locator": null,
      "title": "PR #3: editorial scope and founding-poem framing correction",
      "url": "https://github.com/theguysaccount/charitology/pull/3"
    },
    {
      "locator": null,
      "title": "PR #3 before: problems/the-depth-census",
      "url": "https://github.com/theguysaccount/charitology/blob/905bdd27bb5f16027c3b3ad3c0f5ee3fc18e3e45/src/content/problems/the-depth-census.md"
    },
    {
      "locator": null,
      "title": "PR #3 after: problems/the-depth-census",
      "url": "https://github.com/theguysaccount/charitology/blob/510320528e89f45caa9c42eb5a6eda3d6ad1bede/src/content/problems/the-depth-census.md"
    },
    {
      "locator": null,
      "title": "PR #3 before: journal/ten-dollars",
      "url": "https://github.com/theguysaccount/charitology/blob/905bdd27bb5f16027c3b3ad3c0f5ee3fc18e3e45/src/content/journal/ten-dollars.md"
    },
    {
      "locator": null,
      "title": "PR #3 after: journal/ten-dollars",
      "url": "https://github.com/theguysaccount/charitology/blob/510320528e89f45caa9c42eb5a6eda3d6ad1bede/src/content/journal/ten-dollars.md"
    }
  ],
  "sequence": 1,
  "timeBasis": "pr-merge",
  "type": "artifact-recorded"
}

Review declarations

No public review declaration is recorded for this subject in this edition.

Dated public metadata observations

These observations record only the displayed metadata at inspection. A merge, closed issue or empty review list does not establish research or independent review.

github-pull-request · 2026-10-27T08:20:16.587Z

Observed public object

{
  "base": "975bbbbbd198d4b3c4e1777013d0410588a838b3",
  "draft": false,
  "head": "3653d41717a86db2933b02664d7026a329350a66",
  "mergeCommit": "8df2d0ddbc6d91b9841c6bbb94dbde1fc7c00137",
  "mergedAt": "2026-10-27T08:10:57.000Z",
  "number": 15,
  "state": "closed"
}

be39e645f9291ea3931584665b011df77bfa8340e4d32f36562eb526f8e62396

github-pull-request · 2026-10-27T08:20:16.587Z

Observed public object

{
  "base": "905bdd27bb5f16027c3b3ad3c0f5ee3fc18e3e45",
  "draft": false,
  "head": "510320528e89f45caa9c42eb5a6eda3d6ad1bede",
  "mergeCommit": "3a57d24acc6efd4eb3ae60c59da36ea17c023fb9",
  "mergedAt": "2026-10-26T05:24:43.000Z",
  "number": 3,
  "state": "closed"
}

1ec26b57bd6ef466311b11958d47e9d144ec150ea5689838ae8036eb363aacbf

github-review-list · 2026-10-27T08:20:16.587Z

Observed public object

{
  "prNumber": 3,
  "reviewIds": []
}

3b7b719dbdd25b9937ba6c640f7234921611db30818b5675db41b9fa3534d926

github-issue · 2026-10-27T08:20:16.587Z

Observed public object

{
  "commentCount": 0,
  "number": 1,
  "state": "open"
}

b411d756f95b7434bc8a2a73dd5599f751afe621b2ab673c0e2e7b056d37bb14

Corrections stay public

This ledger reads checked-in public evidence. It does not read private browser registers, publish a local result, assign reviewers or rate charities. New evidence and corrections enter through the repository’s public contribution process.

How to contribute or challenge a claim