Charitology

Open Problems Progress: pinned initial ledger

Open Problems Progress · fixed capture 1 · editorial draft

Open Problems Progress: pinned initial ledger

This is a new capture of explicitly committed sources, not a claim about exact bytes served on an earlier date. Freezing content does not establish independent review, a staffed institution or a research result.

Captured
Declared publication day
Unknown / not declared
Source label
Initial closed R4 edition
Scope
The exact closed research ledger and its explicitly dated progress, with no known January baseline.
Geography
Charitology project
Source baseline
d98f9560b866055971ddea7176c8e5e1028ec58d
  • Unknown historical baselines stay unknown. Capture time is not a source measurement or a historical served-edition timestamp.
  • The pinned ledger as-of time is 2026-10-27T08:31:31.000Z, earlier than this publication capture. No January state is inferred.
  • A fixed edition records its stated sources and scope; it does not establish a staffed institution, independently reviewed research or an annual publication cadence.

AI assistance: Prepared with AI assistance. Independent human review has not been completed.

Edition progress-report-initial-capture · final hash 5723404416f2d8bee1942ba0824512b2b5089c0531c5db78adab1493ce509b2a
Content core 80ced1d51983a0c8886a9317ed858156ad072ed0ed69ad1c96f0300b86fac5c1

Progress recorded by the pinned research ledger

Interval: up to, excluding, . No January baseline was recorded. Unknown earlier states stay unknown.

Editorial changes, qualified research decisions and later withdrawals retain their distinct meanings in this exact projection. A software release or correction is not a solved research problem.

Recorded dispositions
0
Currently supported dispositions
0
Editorial corrections
1
Changed claims
2

The captured problem states

These are the exact ending states supplied by the pinned projection. Earlier starting states remain unknown where no baseline was recorded.

Open problemStarting stateEnding stateEvidence record
closing the feedback loopunknownopenInspect record
discounting the futureunknownopenInspect record
measuring the sourceunknownopenInspect record
moral parliament in practiceunknownopenInspect record
proximity and obligationunknownopenInspect record
story without biasunknownopenInspect record
the agency premiumunknownopenInspect record
the counterfactual problemunknownopenInspect record
the depth censusunknownopenInspect record
the enough questionunknownopenInspect record
the exchange rate problemunknownopenInspect record
the failure commonsunknownopenInspect record
the fragmentation questionunknownopenInspect record
the government questionunknownopenInspect record
the money time exchangeunknownopenInspect record
the optimal restrictionunknownopenInspect record
the overhead replacementunknownopenInspect record
the payout questionunknownopenInspect record
the profession questionunknownopenInspect record
the question of questionsunknownopenInspect record
the replication rateunknownopenInspect record
the status flipunknownopenInspect record
when charity harmsunknownopenInspect record

Ledger edition:2026-10-27-initial · 63af9ab52aa86652f81ea1fac0b7c40aaad46cd8623865918d41ec347f9b2cd3

Inspect this exact ledger edition

Read the complete retained progress projection
{"changedClaimIds":["claim:depth-census-knowledge","claim:ten-dollars-framing"],"counters":{"changedClaims":2,"currentlySupportedDispositions":0,"dispositionsRecorded":0,"editorialCorrections":1},"coverage":{"baselineKnownFrom":null,"limitations":["This initial capture establishes current draft coverage, not a known January baseline or an earlier status history.","The one PR-backed artifact is an editorial correction to two claim subjects; it is not a scientific result, independent review or problem resolution.","Source-derived case descriptions and manuscript bylines do not establish performed Charitology fieldwork or documented complete human authorship.","Public GitHub observations describe only the named objects at their recorded inspection time. An empty returned review list is not proof about reviews elsewhere."],"sourceKeys":["cases/carnegie-libraries","cases/dare","cases/green-revolution","cases/haiti-earthquake-reconstruction","cases/hookworm-campaign","cases/ice-bucket-challenge","cases/one-laptop-per-child","cases/oral-rehydration-therapy-spread","cases/playpumps","cases/polio-eradication","cases/rosenwald-schools","cases/scared-straight","cases/smallpox-eradication","journal/depth-without-a-ladder","journal/ten-dollars","journal/the-feedback-contract","problems/closing-the-feedback-loop","problems/discounting-the-future","problems/measuring-the-source","problems/moral-parliament-in-practice","problems/proximity-and-obligation","problems/story-without-bias","problems/the-agency-premium","problems/the-counterfactual-problem","problems/the-depth-census","problems/the-enough-question","problems/the-exchange-rate-problem","problems/the-failure-commons","problems/the-fragmentation-question","problems/the-government-question","problems/the-money-time-exchange","problems/the-optimal-restriction","problems/the-overhead-replacement","problems/the-payout-question","problems/the-profession-question","problems/the-question-of-questions","problems/the-replication-rate","problems/the-status-flip","problems/when-charity-harms","record/methodology"]},"currentlySupportedDispositionIds":[],"dispositionsRecorded":[],"editionHash":"63af9ab52aa86652f81ea1fac0b7c40aaad46cd8623865918d41ec347f9b2cd3","editionId":"edition:2026-10-27-initial","editorialCorrections":["artifact:pr-3-editorial-framing"],"endingStates":[{"recordId":"problem:closing-the-feedback-loop","status":"open"},{"recordId":"problem:discounting-the-future","status":"open"},{"recordId":"problem:measuring-the-source","status":"open"},{"recordId":"problem:moral-parliament-in-practice","status":"open"},{"recordId":"problem:proximity-and-obligation","status":"open"},{"recordId":"problem:story-without-bias","status":"open"},{"recordId":"problem:the-agency-premium","status":"open"},{"recordId":"problem:the-counterfactual-problem","status":"open"},{"recordId":"problem:the-depth-census","status":"open"},{"recordId":"problem:the-enough-question","status":"open"},{"recordId":"problem:the-exchange-rate-problem","status":"open"},{"recordId":"problem:the-failure-commons","status":"open"},{"recordId":"problem:the-fragmentation-question","status":"open"},{"recordId":"problem:the-government-question","status":"open"},{"recordId":"problem:the-money-time-exchange","status":"open"},{"recordId":"problem:the-optimal-restriction","status":"open"},{"recordId":"problem:the-overhead-replacement","status":"open"},{"recordId":"problem:the-payout-question","status":"open"},{"recordId":"problem:the-profession-question","status":"open"},{"recordId":"problem:the-question-of-questions","status":"open"},{"recordId":"problem:the-replication-rate","status":"open"},{"recordId":"problem:the-status-flip","status":"open"},{"recordId":"problem:when-charity-harms","status":"open"}],"inputHash":"c771560438768493edd9f9fdf6e6926e20e46b50aa32cee5ecdb0e7ac5616107","lateBackfills":["event:artifact-pr-3-editorial-framing-1"],"limitations":["This initial capture establishes current draft coverage, not a known January baseline or an earlier status history.","The one PR-backed artifact is an editorial correction to two claim subjects; it is not a scientific result, independent review or problem resolution.","Source-derived case descriptions and manuscript bylines do not establish performed Charitology fieldwork or documented complete human authorship.","Public GitHub observations describe only the named objects at their recorded inspection time. An empty returned review list is not proof about reviews elsewhere.","Counts describe this pinned ledger; absent starting evidence is unknown, not an assumed January baseline."],"period":{"from":"2026-01-01T00:00:00.000Z","to":"2026-10-27T08:31:31.000Z"},"reviewEvents":[],"startingStates":[{"recordId":"problem:closing-the-feedback-loop","status":null},{"recordId":"problem:discounting-the-future","status":null},{"recordId":"problem:measuring-the-source","status":null},{"recordId":"problem:moral-parliament-in-practice","status":null},{"recordId":"problem:proximity-and-obligation","status":null},{"recordId":"problem:story-without-bias","status":null},{"recordId":"problem:the-agency-premium","status":null},{"recordId":"problem:the-counterfactual-problem","status":null},{"recordId":"problem:the-depth-census","status":null},{"recordId":"problem:the-enough-question","status":null},{"recordId":"problem:the-exchange-rate-problem","status":null},{"recordId":"problem:the-failure-commons","status":null},{"recordId":"problem:the-fragmentation-question","status":null},{"recordId":"problem:the-government-question","status":null},{"recordId":"problem:the-money-time-exchange","status":null},{"recordId":"problem:the-optimal-restriction","status":null},{"recordId":"problem:the-overhead-replacement","status":null},{"recordId":"problem:the-payout-question","status":null},{"recordId":"problem:the-profession-question","status":null},{"recordId":"problem:the-question-of-questions","status":null},{"recordId":"problem:the-replication-rate","status":null},{"recordId":"problem:the-status-flip","status":null},{"recordId":"problem:when-charity-harms","status":null}],"supportWithdrawals":[],"undatedEvents":["event:case-carnegie-libraries-1","event:case-dare-1","event:case-green-revolution-1","event:case-haiti-earthquake-reconstruction-1","event:case-hookworm-campaign-1","event:case-ice-bucket-challenge-1","event:case-one-laptop-per-child-1","event:case-oral-rehydration-therapy-spread-1","event:case-playpumps-1","event:case-polio-eradication-1","event:case-rosenwald-schools-1","event:case-scared-straight-1","event:case-smallpox-eradication-1","event:claim-depth-census-knowledge-1","event:claim-ten-dollars-framing-1","event:manuscript-depth-without-a-ladder-1","event:manuscript-ten-dollars-1","event:manuscript-the-feedback-contract-1","event:method-methodology-1","event:problem-closing-the-feedback-loop-1","event:problem-discounting-the-future-1","event:problem-measuring-the-source-1","event:problem-moral-parliament-in-practice-1","event:problem-proximity-and-obligation-1","event:problem-story-without-bias-1","event:problem-the-agency-premium-1","event:problem-the-counterfactual-problem-1","event:problem-the-depth-census-1","event:problem-the-enough-question-1","event:problem-the-exchange-rate-problem-1","event:problem-the-failure-commons-1","event:problem-the-fragmentation-question-1","event:problem-the-government-question-1","event:problem-the-money-time-exchange-1","event:problem-the-optimal-restriction-1","event:problem-the-overhead-replacement-1","event:problem-the-payout-question-1","event:problem-the-profession-question-1","event:problem-the-question-of-questions-1","event:problem-the-replication-rate-1","event:problem-the-status-flip-1","event:problem-when-charity-harms-1"]}

Raw progress SHA-256: e5e787f314a7b7daf04cef24aa38e7ee06d251b9a7f94dccdf37ca346e2043c2

Member identity and provenance

pinned-research-progress · 712eb240f4697fc4f133b9bcf6eb82196485d5a58a8615e3b1f423264e3b0bd8

181 exact retained source pins. The complete edition manifest contains their identities and hashes.

Inspect all 192 exact source snapshots and artifact hashes

Snapshot text is inert. Original source commits are retained; a later edition baseline can reuse unchanged snapshots only after explicit byte verification. A capture does not establish fresh retrieval of a cited external website.

Text artifacts

  • edition.md · 62883 UTF-8 bytes

    60f3012aad5ea37fdc146ee94121806948c3073c301fb8ef70054ad1cc1bb36b

  • edition.txt · 62883 UTF-8 bytes

    60f3012aad5ea37fdc146ee94121806948c3073c301fb8ef70054ad1cc1bb36b

All fixed captures and the private proposal desk · Compare captures with their limits